The Intriguing Tax Case of Selling Used Personal Garments in Japan

Hello, dear readers! Welcome back to our blog. Today, we’re diving deep into a unique and somewhat unexpected tax case from Japan revolving around selling used personal garments. Prepare to be intrigued!

Overview of the Verdict

Picture this: selling a pre-owned item at a price higher than its original cost. Seems improbable. Yet, that’s the crux of this case. An individual managed to sell their used undergarments, making a profit. Yes, you read that correctly!

Details of the Verdict

The plot thickens here. This wasn’t just a one-off sale. The individual sold their used undergarments a staggering 67 times within a year, raking in more than the initial purchase price on each occasion. This transcends the boundary of merely selling personal items and ventures into the territory of consistent income generation.

Sales with a Profit Motive

These items’ continuous advertising and sale signified a clear intent to profit. Such activity was classified as ‘the transfer of assets conducted continuously for profit,’ setting it apart from the sale of everyday personal items.

A Legal Perspective

This case stands out as it challenges traditional notions of value depreciation associated with used goods. It also prompts intriguing questions regarding how we define income derived from the sale of personal belongings.

The Verdict

So, how did the case conclude? The central issue revolved around whether the proceeds from these sales could be categorized as income from personal property transfer.

Detailed Outcome of the Verdict

Japan’s National Tax Agency decreed that considering the frequency of sales, the profit accrued, and the evident profit motive, the income from selling used undergarments qualified as miscellaneous income. This classification diverged from the typical ‘gain from the transfer of personal property.’ This ruling offers insights into income categorization and underscores the multifaceted nature of tax cases.


That wraps up our discussion for today. If you found this case captivating, please like, share, and subscribe for more enlightening talks. Until our next rendezvous, stay inquisitive and never stop learning!

Leave a Reply

[eac_elementor_tmpl id="10108"]